inline-defaultCreated with Sketch.

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.

share by Nadine Mohamed
SAT vs. ACT: How to Choose the Right Test for College Admissions
Compare SAT and ACT formats, scoring, strengths, and strategies to pick the best test for your college goals. Make an informed choice with this guide.

When preparing for college admissions, one of the biggest decisions students face is whether to take the SAT or the ACT. Both standardized tests are widely accepted by U.S. colleges and universities, and neither is favored over the other by admissions committees. However, the two exams differ in structure, content, scoring, pacing, and even the types of skills they assess.

 

Choosing the test that best matches your academic strengths and test-taking preferences can make a big difference in your confidence, performance, and ultimately, your college applications. This guide will walk you through the key differences between the SAT and ACT and provide practical strategies to help you make the best decision for your goals.

 

SAT vs. ACT: Shared Purpose, Different Emphases

Both the SAT and ACT are designed to evaluate your college readiness. They test similar core skills—reading comprehension, grammar and writing, math, and reasoning—but they do so in different ways.

 

SAT: Emphasis on Critical Thinking and Reasoning

The SAT focuses more on:

  • • Evidence-based reading and writing
  • • Mathematical reasoning and problem-solving
  • • A no-calculator math section
  • • Understanding of graphs, charts, and data interpretation

 

It’s known for testing your ability to reason through problems, understand nuanced language, and solve multi-step questions. Many questions involve interpreting context, analyzing evidence, and applying concepts rather than direct recall.

 

ACT: Emphasis on Curriculum-Based Learning and Speed

The ACT leans more toward:

  • • Straightforward, curriculum-based questions
  • • A unique science reasoning section
  • • Faster pacing—more questions in less time
  • • Calculator use allowed for all math questions

 

The ACT’s science section doesn’t require specific scientific knowledge but tests your ability to read data charts, graphs, and experimental procedures. Students who are more comfortable with direct questions and tight time limits often find this format easier to manage.

 

Key Differences to Note:

  • • Time per question: The SAT allows more time per question on average, which helps students who struggle with pacing.
  • • Science section: Only the ACT has a dedicated science section.
  • • Math tools: The SAT includes a no-calculator section, testing raw math ability.
  • • Number of questions: The ACT generally has more questions across all sections, increasing time pressure.

 

Scoring Systems: SAT vs. ACT

Understanding how the tests are scored can also influence your choice.

 

SAT Scoring:

  • • Total score ranges from 400 to 1600
    • - Math: 200–800
    • - Evidence-Based Reading & Writing: 200–800
  • • No penalty for wrong answers
  • • Scores are scaled to account for test difficulty

 

ACT Scoring:

  • • Composite score ranges from 1 to 36
    • - Average of the four sections: English, Math, Reading, Science
  • • Optional Writing (essay) score is separate
  • • No penalty for wrong answers

 

Most colleges superscore the ACT and SAT, meaning they take your highest scores from different sections across multiple test dates if submitted. Always check individual college policies.

 

Strengths and Preferences: Which Test Fits You Best?

Choosing between the SAT and ACT depends largely on your academic strengths and test-taking personality.

 

Take the ACT if you:

  • • Are a fast reader who can handle time pressure
  • • Excel at interpreting charts, graphs, and experiments
  • • Prefer using a calculator for all math problems
  • • Perform well in science or want to showcase scientific reasoning
  • • Are more comfortable with direct, knowledge-based questions

 

Take the SAT if you:

  • • Prefer more time per question
  • • Are stronger in math problem-solving and reasoning
  • • Can handle more complex reading comprehension
  • • Like working without a calculator for some math
  • • Excel in critical thinking, logic, and evidence analysis

 

Try full-length practice tests for both to compare your comfort level and initial scores. Some students naturally do better on one format due to how the content is presented.

 

Test Accessibility, Flexibility, and Tools

Accessibility features and test experience can also be deciding factors.

 

The SAT:

  • • Is transitioning to a digital format for international students and will soon be fully digital in many regions.
  • • Is typically paper-based in the U.S. (for now)
  • • Includes built-in tools in digital format, such as a graphing calculator
  • • Shorter overall test time in digital version

 

The ACT:

  • • Offers both paper and online testing options
  • • Allows calculator use on all math questions
  • • Includes English Learner (EL) supports like time extensions and glossaries
  • • Lets students move back and forth within each section (unlike some digital SAT versions)

 

Consider the logistics of test-taking—some students find shorter sections easier to focus on (ACT), while others prefer longer, more thoughtful question pacing (SAT).

 

Should You Take Both Tests?

While both tests are equally accepted by colleges, taking both is not usually necessary. Instead, here’s what you should do:

 

  1. 1. Take practice tests for both.
  2. 2. Compare your scores using official conversion charts.
  3. 3. Pick the test you feel most confident and comfortable with.
  4. 4. Focus your preparation on just one test to maximize your performance.

 

Students who try to juggle both often spread themselves too thin. Targeted preparation yields better results.

 

How Many Times Should You Take the Test?

Both the SAT and ACT can be taken multiple times, but more isn’t always better. Most students take the test 2–3 times.

 

Tips:

  • • Take your first official test by spring of your junior year
  • • Retake in summer or early senior year if needed
  • • Focus on quality preparation rather than quantity of attempts
  • • Use free or low-cost prep resources like Khan Academy (SAT) or ACT Academy

 

Test-Optional Colleges: Do SAT and ACT Still Matter?

In recent years, many colleges—especially in light of the COVID-19 pandemic—have moved toward test-optional policies. This means students can apply without submitting SAT or ACT scores, and their applications will still be considered complete.

 

However:

  • Submitting strong scores can still boost your application, especially at selective schools.
  • High scores can qualify you for scholarships, honors programs, and placement opportunities.
  • Some programs (like engineering, business, or merit-based scholarships) still require or prefer test scores.

 

Even in a test-optional landscape, a strong score gives you flexibility and advantage.

 

Other Factors to Consider When Choosing

Besides academic skills and timing, consider:

 

1. Scholarship Requirements

Some merit-based scholarships require minimum ACT or SAT scores—even at test-optional colleges.

 

2. State and School Policies

Certain states use the ACT or SAT as part of high school graduation requirements or automatically administer one test in schools.

 

3. Test Dates and Deadlines

The SAT and ACT offer different test dates. Check which fits your calendar and aligns with college application deadlines.

 

4. Prep Resources and Support

You may find better access to SAT prep (e.g., Khan Academy) or ACT-specific tutors in your area. Use the resources available to you.

 

Final Decision: What Should You Do Next?

Step-by-Step Plan:

  1. 1. Take diagnostic tests for SAT and ACT.
  2. 2. Compare your comfort level, scores, and time management.
  3. 3. Research your target colleges’ preferences or averages.
  4. 4. Choose the test that better fits your strengths and goals.
  5. 5. Build a focused study plan, take practice tests, and seek feedback.

 

SAT or ACT—Choose the Test That Lets You Shine

 

Both the SAT and ACT are excellent tools to demonstrate your academic ability. They are different in design, but neither is “better” than the other. Your decision should come down to how well the test format aligns with your skills, pacing preferences, and long-term goals.

 

By understanding the differences, taking practice tests, and making an informed choice, you can play to your strengths and confidently submit scores that reflect your best abilities to colleges.

 

Are you ready to study abroad? Just browse through more than 110,000 diverse programs worldwide, Educatly offers a diverse array of educational opportunities tailored to your interests and career goals.

 

Signing up is easy! Simply create a profile and explore our extensive database to find the perfect program for you. Whether you're drawn to renowned universities in bustling cities or serene campuses in scenic locations, Educatly ensures you'll find a match that suits your aspirations.

 

To receive personalized guidance every step of the way, schedule a free consultation with one of our experienced educational advisors. They're dedicated to helping you navigate the application process, understand visa requirements, and secure scholarships or financial aid, ensuring you access top-tier educational opportunities with confidence.

 

Read More: The 10 Toughest Exams in the World

user image
by Nadine
Pervious Article
Next Article
Related Tags
Top Views
Trending blogs
Download Educatly App Now
to explore and enjoy the experience!
Do you find this Blog was helpful ?
yesYes
noNo